Deemed Security Interest

.docx
Deemed Security Interest, Power Rental v Forge Group, and PPSA's Mechanics Video Games Ltd is an Australian company which Joanna Heller runs. Joanna imports video game consoles from Japan and sells them through electronics retail stores in Perth, Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane. The contractual terms and conditions with each one of the stores state that Joanna ships 50 consoles to each store for a period of 3 months. Under the agreement, the Joanna receives a weekly payment of 88% for each sold console (i.e. the value of each sold console minus 12% commission of the store). Upon the end of the 3 month period, the stores must ship the unsold consoles back to Joanna. Joanna's accountant, who is not familiar with PPSA, does not register security interest for the consoles for any of the stores. This arrangement worked well with all retail stores, except two: (1) Brisbane Store and Perth Store: Brisbane Store: the owner of this store, Jacob did not like the suggested arrangement as he thought that there was a good chance that most of consoles would be sold during the Christmas week, which fell outside of the 3 month period. Accordingly, in his negotiation with Joanna, he insisted on having the option to purchase any of the unsold consoles at the end of the 3 month period. Joanna happily agreed with this request and the parties incorporated it in the agreement. Unfortunately, a month after the delivery of the consoles, Brisbane store experienced serious financial difficulties. While no Insolvency Administrator was appointed, the store did not to pay its weekly payment to Joanna; Perth Store: in contrast to other stores, this was a new store. The original location was well known for years as selling fresh vegetables and fruits products. However, the store was sold to Mary, who decided to move into the new business of selling electronics. Right before signing the agreement with Joanna, Mary sent a letter to all her suppliers, introducing herself and describing the nature of the new business. Unfortunately, and similar to Brisbane's Store, Perth's store faced severe financial difficulties. The Insolvency Administrator has been appointed and no payments are made to Joanna. Question 1 Would Joanna be able to repossess the consoles from the Brisbane Store? Explain. In the case with the Brisbane Store, Joanna's company had an agreement that allowed the store owner to buy unsold consoles. This created a legal right for Joanna's company over the consoles. However, this right needed to be registered under the law to be fully protected. Since it wasn't registered, Joanna might face challenges in repossessing the consoles if the store faces financial trouble. In simple terms, because the legal right wasn't officially recorded, Joanna's company might have a harder time getting back the consoles from the Brisbane Store if the store can't pay. Legal rules can be complex, so getting specific advice is importan
Question 2 How you would change your answer (if at all) had the Insolvency Administrator been appointed for the Brisbane Store? When an Insolvency Administrator is appointed, it signifies that the store is in a state of financial distress or insolvency. In such cases, the PPSA takes on added importance in determining the rights of various parties involved. In cases of insolvency, the PPSA's rules and priorities become crucial in determining who has rights to the unsold consoles. If Joanna's company had properly registered the security interest arising from the option to purchase, it would likely have a better chance of asserting ownership over the consoles ahead of other unsecured creditors. The Insolvency Administrator would be responsible for overseeing the store's financial affairs, including determining how assets are distributed to creditors. Proper registration of the security interest under the PPSA would strengthen Joanna's company's position, but the final outcome would depend on various legal factors and the decisions of the Insolvency Administration Question 3 How would you change your answer (if at all) to Question 2 (i.e. the Insolvency Administrator had been appointed to Brisbane Store) had Joanna's accountant registered the security interest against the Brisbane Store a month after the agreement formation? In this scenario, where Joanna's accountant registered the security interest against the Brisbane Store a month after the agreement was made and the Insolvency Administrator is now involved: 1. Security Interest Registration: Registering the security interest after the agreement formation is beneficial. It helps establish Joanna's company's rights to the unsold consoles under the PPSA. This registered interest could improve the company's position in asserting ownership over the consoles in case of the store's insolvency. 2. Insolvency Administrator: The involvement of the Insolvency Administrator means the store is facing financial difficulties. The Administrator is responsible for managing the store's assets and distributing them among creditors. The PPSA-registered security interest would give Joanna's company better standing in the distribution process, potentially increasing the chances of reclaiming the consoles.
In summary, registering the security interest against the Brisbane Store after the agreement formation would strengthen Joanna's company's position, particularly in the context of the store's insolvency. The involvement of the Insolvency Administrator would mean that proper registration improves the chances of the company reclaiming the consoles compared to other unsecured creditors. However, legal nuances may apply, so seeking tailored legal advice remains important for a comprehensive understanding of the situation. Question 4 Would Joanna be able to repossess the consoles from the Perth Store? In the case of the Perth Store, Joanna's situation is different due to the new ownership and communication regarding the change in business. Let's examine whether Joanna would be able to repossess the consoles from the Perth Store: 1. Change in Business and Communication: When Mary took over the Perth Store and changed its business from selling fresh produce to electronics, she sent a letter to all her suppliers informing them of this change. While the letter might not directly create a security interest, it could potentially impact the nature of the agreement between Joanna's company and the store. 2. Purchase and Money Owed: The details provided do not mention whether a formal agreement was entered into with the Perth Store, similar to the other retail stores. If there was a formal agreement outlining the terms of supply, payment, and return of unsold consoles, that agreement would be important to determine Joanna's rights. 3. Security Interest: Since there's no mention of a security interest being created in the scenario involving the Perth Store, it's crucial to consider whether Joanna's company had any legal claims over the consoles, especially in the context of the store's financial difficulties and appointment of an Insolvency Administrator. 4. Insolvency Administrator: The fact that an Insolvency Administrator has been appointed for the Perth Store indicates financial distress. The Insolvency Administrator oversees the store's financial matters, and if there are any competing claims, the PPSA-registered security interest would be significant in establishing Joanna's company's rights. In summary, whether Joanna's company can repossess the consoles from the Perth Store would depend on various factors, including the nature of the agreement (if any), the presence of a security interest, the communication from the store owner, and the involvement of the Insolvency Administrator. If a valid security interest was established and registered, Joanna's company would likely have a stronger position to reclaim the consoles in case of the store's insolvency. However, as legal situations can be complex, seeking
Uploaded by DrWolfPerson804 on coursehero.com