Market Failure: Externalities
Government Policy Options
RegulationThe government can respond to externalities through command-and-control policies or market-based policies.
Learning ObjectivesDescribe the role of government regulation in addressing externalities
- Command-and-control regulation requires or forbids certain behaviors with the goal of addressing an externality.
- Regulation is difficult to implement and enforce correctly.
- Command-and-control regulation can come in the form of government-imposed standards, targets, process requirements, or outright bans.
- The allocation of tradable permits is a market-based policy that has been primarily used to combat pollution.
- Negative Externality: A detremental effect suffered by a party due to a transaction it was not a part of.
Command-and-control regulation can come in the form of government-imposed standards, targets, process requirements, or outright bans. Such measures make certain behaviors either required or forbidden with the goal of addressing the externality. For example, the government may make it illegal for a company to dump certain chemicals in a river. By doing so, the government hopes to protect the environment or other companies or individuals that use the river that would otherwise suffer a negative impact.
In practice, implementing regulation effectively is difficult. It requires the regulator to have in-depth knowledge of a certain industry or sphere of economic activity. If done incorrectly, regulation can introduce inefficiency. For example, if the government makes it illegal to dump in the river, the companies and their customers may suffer because the products must be produced using less efficient methods. On the other hand, if the government allows too much to be dumped in the river, they have failed to mitigate the negative externality.
If the government is unsure of how to effectively regulate the market, it should seek other methods of mitigating the externality. Advocates of market-based policies for reducing negative externalities point to the difficulty of creating and enforcing effective regulation for reasons why the government should create systems of incentives and disincentives instead of using the force of regulation.
TaxCorrective taxes incentivize economic actors to reduce the production of goods or services generating negative externalities.
Learning ObjectivesDescribe the role of taxes in addressing externalities
- A corrective tax is a market-based policy option used by the government to address negative externalities.
- Taxes increase the cost of producing goods or services generating the externality, thus encouraging firms to produce less output.
- The tax should be set equal to the value of the negative externality, which is very difficult to do in practice.
- Corrective taxes increase efficiency and provide the government with revenues as well.
- Pigovian tax: A tax applied to a market activity that is generating negative externalities (costs for somebody else).
In the case of negative externalities, the social cost of an activity is greater than the private cost of the activity. In such a case, the market outcome is not efficient and may lead to overproduction of the good. Taxes make it more expensive for firms to produce the good or service generating the externality, thus providing an incentive to produce less of it. As the figure demonstrates, a tax shifts the marginal private cost curve up. In response, producers change the output to the socially-optimum level.
Take environmental pollution as an example. The private cost of pollution to a polluter is less than its social cost. If the government levies a tax on pollution, it increases the polluter's private cost. The polluter now has an incentive to generate less pollution.
The level of the corrective tax is intended to counterbalance the externality. In practice, however, it is extremely difficult for the government to determine the appropriate level for the tax. Moreover, in determining the tax level, the government might come under pressure from various interest groups that would benefit from a higher or lower taxation level. Nevertheless, by introducing corrective taxes in response to negative externalities the government can not only increase efficiency, but raise revenues as well.
QuotasTradable permits are a market-based approach allowing the government to limit negative externalities produced by a group of firms.
Learning ObjectivesEvaluate a permit system as a method to address externalities
- A permit is a right to produce a certain amount of a negative externality, such as pollution.
- Permits are traded among firms. Firms that are able to cheaply reduce production of the externality can sell permits to firms that are unable to make such reductions and are willing to pay for the permits.
- Regardless of the initial allocation of permits, the market for permits achieves an outcome that is more efficient for society.
- Permit: The right to produce a given amount of a negative externality (for example, the right to emit a specific volume of a pollutant).
- quota: A restriction on the import of something to a specific quantity.
Tradable permits are one of the market-based approaches the government can use to address externalities. In the past tradable permits have been primarily used to control pollution.
When pursuing this approach the government sets a limit or cap on the amount of a pollutant that may be emitted. It then allocates emissions permits up to the specified limit among firms. The permits represent the right to emit or discharge a specific volume of a specified pollutant. Firms are required to hold a number of permits equivalent to their emissions. Firms that need to increase their volume of emissions must buy permits from firms that require fewer of them. This transfer is referred to as a trade. In effect, the buyer is paying a charge for polluting, while the seller is being rewarded for having reduced emissions. The outcome achieved by the market for permits is more efficient, regardless of the initial allocation of permits.
The market for tradable permits creates incentives for firms to produce less pollution. Firms that have a high cost of reducing emissions are willing to pay for the permits, while those that can reduce emissions in the most cost-efficient manner will do so and sell their permits. Tradable permits thus achieve a desired level of the externality by allowing the market to determine which market actors can create the externality.
There are several active trading programs for air pollutants. For greenhouse gases the largest is the European Union Emission Trading Scheme. In the United States there is a national market for sulfur dioxide emissions to reduce acid rain. Markets for other pollutants tend to be smaller and more localized.