'
I
o
X
Professors
required
each
student
to
buy
10
te'xt':books,;
regardllegs
of
the
price.
X
(O
Asthe
price
of
energy
drinks
increased
relative
to
the
'
price
of
coffee
between
2020
and
2022,
studekts
decreased
their
consumption
of
energy
drinks
and
increased
their
consumption
of
coffee,
v
@
The
quality
of
textbooks
increased
dramatically
from
2020
to
2022,
with
textbook
companies
bundling
new
online
study
aids
with
their
books,
but
this
quality
change
is
hard
to
measure.
I¥
Points:
@
0.25/
1
Explanation:
Close
Explanation
~
One
reason
that
price
indexes
such
as
the
UPI
overstate
inflation
is
that
they
use
a
fixed
basket
of
goods.
In
reality,
when
the
price
of
a
good
increases,
people
tend
to
buy
less
of
it.
For
example,
during
the
period
shown
in
this
problem,
the
price
of
energy
drinks
rose
dramatically,
but
if
the
characteristics
of
all
the
goods
were
held
constant,
you
would
expect students
to
buy
fewer
energy
drinks
as
a
result.
Therefore,
a
measure
of
inflation
that
assumes
that
students
would
not
reduce
their
consumption
of
energy
drinks,
even
as
their
price
rose,
would
overstate
inflation.
However,
if
students
cannot
alter
their
bundle—for
example,
because
professors
require
them
to
buy
10
textbooks,
regardless
of
the
price—then
the
UPI
would
be
a
more
accurate
description
of
the
true
cost
of
attending
college.
Another
reason
that
price
indexes
overstate
inflation
is
that
they
assume
the
quality
of
a
good
doesn't
change
from
year
to
year.
Therefore,
if
the
price
of
something
increases
because
of
increases
in
quality,
the
price
index
might
overstate
the
cost
increase
of
that
item
due
to
unmeasured
quality
improvements.
For
example,
it's
reasonable
to
think
that
part
of
the
price
increase
of
the
textbooks
was
payment
for
the
new
online
study
aids,
not
an
increase
in
the price
of
the
same
textbooks
that
were
sold
in
2020.
Yet
another
reason
that
price
indexes
overstate
inflation
is
that
they
don't
account
for
the
benefits
of
new
goods.
When
new
goods,
like
new
motor
scooters,
are
introduced,
consumers
can
spend
their
money
on
more
things.
As
a
result,
the
value
of
each
dollar
they
have
increases.
!
Because
the
UPI
doesn't
account
for
new
goods,
it
underestimates
what
a
dollar
is
worth
when
new
goods
are
introduced
and,
thus,
overestimates
inflation.
Try
Another
Version
SRR
SR
S
R
S
A
B
A